FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
FROM: WAYNE UNZE (797-1100)
VAUGHAN COMPANY BUSINESS
OPPORTUNITIES
RE: THE ART OF DUE DILIGENCE
Thinking about buying or
investing in a business? How can you
tell if it is really
a viable and safe business with
long-range income potential? The answer
is in
proper due diligence - legalese
meaning, turn over enough rocks to make sure
there are no scorpions in the
flower garden.
Many would-be entrepreneurs
or investors think that reviewing a company's
balance sheets and income
statements constitutes due diligence.
But that should
only be the start of a more
elaborate process. Here are some other
items that
warrant close inspection before you
sign the final closing documents.
1. Client List. Find out if most of the company's business is
done with a few
entities or individuals, or if there
is a diversified and extensive customer base.
If
there is a limited clientele, you
may want to meet with some of them as a part
of your due diligence process
to determine if they will remain loyal after the sale.
Because of the seller’s need
for confidentiality, any such contacts would occur
just prior to closing and under
the seller’s scrutiny.
2. Key Employees. If you are looking at a company that relies
on key people to
perform its services and you do not
possess the necessary skills to run the
company in their absence, protect
yourself. A confidential meeting with a
key
employee can help you determine his
company loyalty. Our experience dictates
that most employees will remain
after the sale, because the change of ownership
is not nearly as traumatic as
a change in employment.
3. Books and Records. Tax returns are signed under penalty of
perjury and
should be used to verify income
statements, so try to obtain copies for the last
three years. Other records to peruse include: accounts receivable and payable;
any property or equipment
leases, pertinent contracts, warranties and copies of
the gross receipts tax
statements for the past year.
4. Equipment and Inventory. Asset-intensive businesses warrant an
inspection
of the assets to determine if
the inventory is marketable and the equipment is in
good repair and adequate for the
purposes for which it is intended. Buying
any
business with obsolete equipment or
inventory is like buying a car without an
engine.
5. Industry Outlook. If you are paying for "goodwill",
make sure there is some.
Research the industry on the
internet to see if it is still a healthy and growing area
of commerce. Try to determine where the subject business
ranks with respect to
its market share and work with
the seller to develop a list of the things you can do
to improve its position.
6. Chattel and Tax Lien Search. The closing attorney should order these very
important searches to uncover any
encumbrances that may exist against the assets
of the business. Smart buyers run searches on both the
business and the owner to
make sure all bases are
covered.
7. Suitable Lease. If you are buying a business with a
seven-year promissory
note, a three-year lease isn’t
very attractive. The seller’s leasehold
interests can
be transferred to the buyer in
one of three ways: a lease assignment, a
sublease or
a new lease. If there is plenty of time
remaining on the existing lease (renewal
options included), it is sometimes
easier for the seller to simply assign the lease to
the buyer, subject to the
landlord’s approval. In some instances
(very few) the
seller may be able to sublet the
property to the buyer. If there is only
a little time
remaining on the lease, it is often
better for the buyer to simply negotiate a new
lease with the landlord. Any purchase agreement should reflect the
fact that the
purchase is contingent upon the
buyer’s acceptance of a suitable new lease or
lease assignment.
8. Professional Assistance. A good CPA is necessary to review financial
records, while an experienced
business attorney can advise you on legal matters
such as those surrounding
important contracts, leases and other agreements.
Spending a couple of
thousand dollars on professionals prior to a major
investment can be a cheap price to pay
for peace of mind.
A couple of year’s ago, a
distraught gentleman (let’s call him Reed), visited my
office and related a sad
tale. He had recently bought a business
directly from an
owner and was having serious
doubts about its future. When I asked
him what
due diligence he had performed,
he said he had looked at profit and loss
statements, had reviewed the lease and
had inspected the inventory and
equipment. He had also researched the
industry to satisfy himself that there was
remaining growth potential.
Unfortunately, Reed tried to
save a buck by using a standard Bill of Sale bought at
a stationary store rather
than relying on a business attorney to draft the proper
closing documents and order a
chattel and tax lien search. The rest of
his story
reads like a Steven King
novel. Four major pieces of equipment
were actually
leased and in arrears; the company
had not paid any payroll or gross receipts taxes
in two years; and there was
$20,000 in inventory that was about to be confiscated
by the vendor for
nonpayment.
Essentially, Reed had
purchased a lemon and no amount of post-sale lamenting
was going to turn it into
lemonade. Hopefully, Reed’s dismal
experience will
have a positive effect in motivating
future buyers to do their pre-sale homework.
Due diligence is not just a phrase, it is a requisite for peace of mind.